When shopping for a new firewall, it’s easy to get caught up in the throughput numbers. After all, who doesn’t want the fastest firewall possible? However, it’s important to remember that throughput is not the only factor to consider. You also need to look at the IPS/SSL/application/NFGW/threat throughput.
IPS throughput is the amount of traffic that the firewall can inspect for intrusions.
SSL throughput is the amount of traffic that the firewall can decrypt and inspect for threats.
Application throughput is the amount of traffic that the firewall can inspect for applications.
NFGW throughput is the amount of traffic that the firewall can inspect for network flows.
Threat throughput is the amount of traffic that the firewall can inspect for threats.
In general, you’ll need more throughput for IPS and SSL inspection than for application and NFGW inspection. This is because IPS and SSL inspection are more computationally intensive.
The following table compares the throughput of the FortiGate 600F and the Palo Alto Networks PA-3410:
| Feature | FortiGate 600F | Palo Alto Networks PA-3410 |
|---|---|---|
| Throughput | 140 Gbps | 11.5 Gbps |
| IPS throughput | 10.5 Gbps | 4.9 Gbps |
| SSL throughput | 9 Gbps | 0.365 Gbps |
| Application throughput | 10 Gbps | 5.1 Gbps |
| NFGW throughput | 55 Gbps | 4.7 Gbps |
| Threat throughput | 10.5 Gbps | 4.9 Gbps |
As you can see, the FortiGate 600F has higher throughput than the PA-3410 for all features except SSL inspection. However, it’s important to note that the FortiGate 600F also has a higher price tag.
So, which firewall should you buy? It depends on your needs. If you need the highest possible throughput for all features, then the FortiGate 600F is the better choice. However, if you’re on a budget or you don’t need the highest possible throughput for SSL inspection, then the PA-3410 is a good option.
Ultimately, the best way to choose a firewall is to talk to a security expert. They can help you assess your needs and recommend the best firewall for your environment.
In addition to throughput, there are other factors to consider when choosing a firewall, such as:
-
- Security features: The firewall should have the security features you need to protect your network from threats.
-
- Management features: The firewall should be easy to manage and configure.
-
- Performance: The firewall should be able to handle the traffic volume and processing requirements of your network.
-
- Cost: The firewall should be affordable for your budget.
Sure, here is the comparison of the FortiGate 600F and the Palo Alto Networks PA-3440:
| Feature | FortiGate 600F | Palo Alto Networks PA-3440 |
|---|---|---|
| Throughput | 140 Gbps | 130 Gbps |
| IPS throughput | 10.5 Gbps | 7.8 Gbps |
| SSL throughput | 9 Gbps | 1.8 Gbps |
| Application throughput | 10 Gbps | 6.1 Gbps |
| NFGW throughput | 55 Gbps | 48 Gbps |
| Threat throughput | 10.5 Gbps | 7.8 Gbps |
| Security features | Next-generation firewall (NGFW), intrusion prevention system (IPS), application control, URL filtering, sandboxing, threat intelligence | NGFW, IPS, application control, URL filtering, sandboxing, threat intelligence |
| Management features | Centralized management, policy automation, reporting and analysis | Centralized management, policy automation, reporting and analysis |
| Performance | Can handle high traffic volumes and complex security policies | Can handle high traffic volumes and complex security policies |
As you can see, the FortiGate 600F and the PA-3440 are Not very similar in terms of features and performance. The FortiGate 600F has a higher throughput, but the PA-3440 has lower features. Ultimately, the best firewall for you will depend on your specific needs and budget.
Here are some additional factors to consider when choosing between the FortiGate 600F and the PA-3440:
-
- Security features: The FortiGate 600F has a wider range of security features than the PA-3440. For example, the FortiGate 600F includes sandboxing and threat intelligence, which are not available on the PA-3440.
-
- Management features: Both firewalls offer centralized management and policy automation. However, the FortiGate 600F also offers reporting and analysis features that are not available on the PA-3440.
-
- Performance: Both firewalls can handle high traffic volumes and complex security policies. However, the FortiGate 600F may be a better choice if you have a very high-traffic network.
-
- Cost: The FortiGate 600F is more expensive than the PA-3440. However, the FortiGate 600F may be a better value if you need additional security features and management capabilities.
If you are still unsure which firewall is right for you, it is best to consult with a security expert. They can help you assess your needs and recommend the best firewall for your environment.
I would like to add that these are Lab reports that are done in strict testing environments so when you compare with Live environment the actual data is at least 50% less than what is shown in Datasheet Buy Wisely or contact me for the same